Lobster Rolls at Sam’s Chowderhouse, Half Moon Bay

by foodhoe on January 10, 2011

4210 North Cabrillo Hwy, Half Moon Bay, CA 94019  | 650.712.0245 | reservations | website

Over the holidays, Mr. K and I drove out to Half Moon Bay a couple of times to pickup dungeness crabs from one of the boats in the marina.  This year the crabs are big and feisty and there were numerous boats selling then straight out of the crates they were hauled up in.

Both times, we stopped at Sam’s Chowderhouse for the famous Lobster Roll and of course, chowder.  It’s conveniently down the road, has expansive views of the bay with a lovely outside patio.  You can easily get a table if you are early, otherwise, get in line… The first time we elected to sit out in the back since there was a bit of sunshine, although the winds were blowing quite vigorously.  Despite the chilly weather, we really enjoyed the view.  Sam’s opened in 2006 and is quite popular, especially after its lobster roll was named as being in the top five best sandwiches in America on NBC’s The Today Show in 2007.

You really can’t go wrong ordering the chowder, I loved the New England style Chowder ($6.95/cup).  It’s rich with Little neck clams, Yukon gold potatoes, and flavored with bits of smoked bacon, onion and thyme.  According to the menu, they don’t thicken their chowder with tons of flour, just the natural ingredients in a creamy, savory broth.

And Mr. K enjoyed a cup of the Manhattan Clam Chowder ($6.95), which is tomato-based and full of the savory flavor of little neck clams, vegetables, and herbs.  You don’t see Manhattan style chowder very often, but this is so good I wonder why this is so.

We split one of the Lobster Rolls ($19.95), which comes with a bowl of coleslaw and chips.  Delicious.   The buns are the New England top-loaders which have had the sides removed to flatten them out and are then buttered and grilled to a lightly crisped exterior.   The sandwich is literally overflowing with large chunks of lobster meat, including the buttery claws, spindly legs and all.

The buttery toasted buns meld perfectly with succulent chunks of meat that have been generously dosed with butter.  It’s outrageously decadent and really finger licking good.

On the second visit, we met Mank, and we decided to stray from the standard side of plain chips and upgraded to the Old Bay Fries, (for an additional $2) which were dusted with Old Bay spice mixture that we liked very much.

We also tried it with the Polenta Fries, which were big blocks of battered and fried polenta that I felt would have been better topped with marinara and cheese…

It was creamy and delicious with a delicately crispy shell,  but too big and hefty to be considered a side dish.  My advice, go with the Old Bay Fries or potato chips.

The Caesar Salad was forgettable topped with coarse shreds of grated parmesan cheese and just a few Garlic Scented Croutons ($8.95)

The Seafood Ceviche ($11.50) made bay scallops, and shrimp was on the bland side, but were saved when served over the crunchy tortilla chips with slices of avocado.  Mr. K thought that the bay scallops were squishy little fish balls lol!  We were not impressed with either of these salady appetizers, but both times the chowder and lobster sandwiches were so good that I’d rather not be distracted by side dishes anyways…

On our second visit, it was cold and cloudy so we sat inside.  We enjoyed the same mesmerizing view; and even better… the soup didn’t get cold right away, so we were able to nosh our meal at a more leisurely pace.

On the way out, I saw Sam’s Chowdermobile parked in the lot, which brings the lobster rolls and chowder out on the road, you can get up to the minute location updates on twitter.  I hope to run into them when they setup shop in Golden Gate Park one of these days!

Sam's Chowder House on Urbanspoon

{ 9 comments… read them below or add one }

Rosa January 10, 2011 at 1:00 pm

Wow, that lobster rolls is irresistible and so cheap (at least for us Europeans)! scrummy food and gorgeous view.




Gastronomer January 10, 2011 at 1:47 pm

This place sounds absolutely delicious! I love lobster rolls with all of my heart. I’m going to try and chase the truck down when I’m in The Bay next. Lobsta, baby!


Bonnibella January 10, 2011 at 3:24 pm

Love everything there! Especially the view!


Michelle January 10, 2011 at 4:47 pm

I just about fell over when I saw the lobster roll! Wow!


foodhoe January 11, 2011 at 9:52 am

rosa, they are so irresistible I want to go back already!
gastronomer, me too but I know I couldn’t keep up with you runner gastrogirl
bonibella, it was your post that inspired me to seek this place out!
michell, lol


Single Guy Ben January 11, 2011 at 3:03 pm

I tried a mini version of the lobster roll from the truck at Eat Real two years ago. I don’t remember much about it, but maybe it’s better as a larger roll and with that view!


Jun Belen January 11, 2011 at 9:58 pm

I’ve been wanting to try Sam’s famous lobster roll and their clam chowder. Not sure if they’re in Golden Gate Park during the winter. I’ve been keeping an eye out for them in Off the Grid but I guess they’re still not a part of it. Some day…


grace January 12, 2011 at 9:37 am

lobstah, chowdah, and some FIERCE fries–looks like a winner to me!


hungry dog February 14, 2011 at 1:22 pm

Went here a few weeks ago for the first time and fell in love. That lobster roll is out of this world.


Leave a Comment

Spam protection by WP Captcha-Free

Previous post:

Next post: